Reviews

Rate Show

So niche, so nice!
Were you a middle schooler who spent hours at the family desktop looking at rotten.com with one eye while the other kept watch for your parents, not keen to explain why you were clicking through photos of a man whose hand went through a meat grinder (and not sure you could even if they asked?) Have you seen Alive, the made for TV movie about the Uruguayan rugby team whose plane crashed into the Andes in 1972 more times than you’ll admit? Do you have an interest in the tragic and macabre that leaves you feeling a mix of revulsion and fascination that you can’t express in the group chat amongst discussions of potty training and the children’s choir performance on America’s Got Talent? If so, then Marked Safe is the niche haven you’ve always sought but never knew existed. Listening to an episode feels like having a sleepover with those girls you always wanted to find who too indulge their morbid curiosities. I’m not usually a fan of podcasts with multiple hosts as I generally find banter grating, but Brianne and Melanie have the cutest friendship, are hilarious, and the perfect complement to one another. Listening to their back and forth feels like hanging out with friends, and you can tell they genuinely care for one another, which is so sweet. They present the heartbreaking, jaw-dropping disasters they cover with a respectful balance of solemnity and dark humor. They cover the kind of stuff people like us pore over on Wikipedia at 2 am. My real life friends don’t share in my interest in disasters and I’m so glad I’ve found a community of horrible ghouls through Brianne and Melanie’s podcast who do.

Looveee
I stumbled on to this podcast through TikTok and I cannot be more happy that I did. These two women are so incredible. They are warm, funny, silly, and tell amazing stories. I love how they are both so different and complement each other well. The stories are entertaining without being disrespectful to those involved. I feel like I’m amongst my friends listening to their stories. 5/5 -From Me

Thank you ❤️
I just started and I’m on episode two and I am great full A. For your respect to the victims B. For referring to migrant workers as undocumented and not “illegal” I will continue to listen you earned a fan

Just hanging with friends
I love the back and forth here, it feels like I’m sitting and having a casual conversation with friends. The stories are great, I’m glad I found this podcast.

Fantastic
I could listen to these two for hours on end, old content - new content - doesn’t matter. It’s always interesting and engaging.

Refreshing
It’s so refreshing to find a podcast of this nature with two hosts who have the most beautiful, kind souls. Their story telling is so captivating that you feel like they’re your long lost best friends.

Recommend this to everyone!
I LOVE this podcast. I log a lot of listening time at my job, and have been through heaps of podcasts (mainly true crime) start to finish and let me tell you, none of them have kept me on the edge of my seat more consistently than this one. The chemistry between the hosts (both ladies which I love) is wonderful and genuine, they keep the show light & entertaining while still effectively telling the stories with careful respect to the victims and in depth follow through.

Stories from your Best Friends
I love the way Melanie and Brianne take turns telling stories so one of them is always learning about the disaster at the same time as us listeners. We get the hosts' genuine reactions to events they're sometimes hearing about for the first time. If you're looking for a highly-professional, syndicated, monotonous podcast, this definitely isn't for you. However, if you're looking for a fun-loving, chaotic gossip session between two besties (complete with side stories about their lives, children, and a hint of barely-concealed liberal politics), this is your podcast! Their half-scripted episodes teach listeners just as much about your two cohosts as they do about the disasters they discuss, and by the end of a couple of episodes it feels like you're having extended gossip sessions with your best friends.

oh em gee
i love this podcast i discovered it from a tiktok and i’ve binge listened since i found it. i’ve recommended it to every person i could possibly recommend it to. these ladies r just so funny and so fun to listen to and it was exactly the podcast i was looking for. absolutely love.

Obsessed!
So respectful and amazing! Just started this podcast from finding their tiktok and it is great!

A new favorite!!
Found this podcast from a tiktok and I’m hooked!! You guys are wonderful!!

New favorite!
I like how it’s one story each episode told to each other. Very easy to follow and these ladies are super respectful to the stories they’re telling. Can’t wait to hear more!

Hooked
I saw a preview on TikTok and was hooked. Immediately subscribed and haven’t stopped listening!! I love the hearing the friendship as well as the stories!

♥️ This
As a lady who loves podcast but also watched Ida on my news channel all day as it unfolded this is the podcast for me. I love how they keep such morbid things so light.

Awesome addition to my rotation
As a longtime IRL ghoul, this immediately became part of my weekly rotation. I love a good true crime pod, but disasters are even more in my wheelhouse. They’re dealt with in a surprisingly sensitive and thoughtful way that honors the victims, while still being funny, as we all rubberneck together.

Love these girls!
Their friendship and morbid humor make my week. I feel like I’m chatting with my friends about crappy/weird things that happen in the world and I’m glad to know I’m not the old person who enjoys learning about it. Praises to Brianne and Melanie!

Humanizing and personal portraits of disasters
I recently found this podcast by accident through comments on a post about a local disaster’s anniversary. From Pokémon Go accidents to escalators to a surprisingly horrific Christmas party, I get a weekly distraction from our current disaster filled world. Brianne and Melanie paint deeply humanizing and personal portraits of the people impacted from the disaster in addition to discussing systemic and technical issues that contributed to the disaster. There’s always a dose of humor in each episode, though never at the expense of the victims, which is achieved through the host’s rapport with each other.

10/10 Koalas Approve
Seriously, listen to this podcast. It is the highlight of my week. Wins every bracket. Amazing audio.

Funny, detailed and heartfelt
I think my most favorite thing about Melanie and Brianne is how they honor victims of the tragedies they share. It would be easy to just report on the facts—which they do very well—but they give that extra effort to really help the listener understand and get to know the victims. They are also flipping hilarious. I feel like I’m hanging out with my best friends just listening to good stories. I laugh out loud every single episode. Keep it up ladies and TAG.

Instant Friends
I discovered this podcast when I was looking for podcasts on the Costa Concordia disaster. I instantly subscribed and joined Patreon!! I am now trying to catch up on all the episodes!! Highly recommend this podcast!! The topics are heavy but they deliver it with great respect!!
The topics are covered in an interesting, yet respectful, way, with a bit of humor to help cut through the darkness. Brianne and Melanie have great chemistry and provide amazing content with thoroughly researched topics.

These two are killing it!
I love their easy rapport, their depth of research and the fascinating content. Keep it up Bri-anie! (See what I did there?)

BEST!
I love this podcast. It’s interesting, informative, has plenty of levity (but doesn’t feel disrespectful), and feels like spending time with friends. I couldn’t be happier to be a horrible ghoul. Also: feel better, Melanie!

Great podcast
I love this podcast as much as I love tacos. highly recommend.

2 friends who love disaster stories!
I am not one of those people who likes watching disaster/cold case/serial killer documentaries, but I love this podcast! Listening to Brianne and Melanie talk is like hanging out with 2 of your good friends...friends who discuss disasters like train derailments, anyway. I wish I was friends with them IRL! Episodes are well-researched, more serious topics are handled with sensitivity, and possible triggers are listed in the episode notes of each episode.

Love this
I love this podcast! The hosts are so fun and relatable and I absolutely adore them :)

Love this podcast
I have been listening since the 2nd or 3rd episode, it’s very well done. The episodes are a good length and I enjoy the banter between the hosts. I also appreciate that they aren’t afraid to say how they feel about our current world and leadership (or lack thereof). My favorites are usually always Brianne’s compilation episodes!

I’m such a horrible ghoul
This is for real my favorite disaster podcast to listen to and I feel like I’m chatting to my bffs ( yeah. I may talk back sometimes when they say something ) There’s great research and really fun banter between them I also have several mom group virtual friends and they’re some of my dearest girls. I completely relate and adore them. Keep it up ❤️

Hands Down Best Disaster Pod
Thanks for filling the void missing in disaster podcasts! You ladies are doing a great job. I binged every episode the day I discovered it... keep up the great work!

Love these two ladies!!
These are just the best podcast!! They really do a lot of research. I have learned a lot!! Love both of you and anxiously waiting for each new episode!!